Nationwide Affinity Insurance Company of America now owes its policyholder $7,136,000 of affirmed compensatory damages plus attorney fees to be recalculated, after Washington's Court of Appeals, Division III, reversed a $47 million punitive award and dismissed her Insurance Fair Conduct Act claim in a published opinion filed November 10 (Shiferaw v. Nationwide, No. 39643-6-III). The findings of bad faith, negligence and a Consumer Protection Act violation stand.
Judge Murphy wrote the opinion, with Chief Judge Staab and Judge Lawrence-Berrey concurring. The judgment grew from a $200,000 liability limit. Meseret Shiferaw's August 2017 crash in Alberta killed her three children and injured her husband, Solomon Agere. He sued her in August 2019 after Nationwide had declined for two years to tender the limit. Insurance Business reported on November 11 that the ruling wiped more than $87 million from the judgment. It leaves untouched the $17,123,927.71 arbitration award Nationwide paid in full in August 2020, more than 85 times the limit.
Key Takeaways
- The court reversed $87,136,000 of the damages: $47 million punitive, $20 million IFCA noneconomic and a $20,136,000 IFCA enhancement, and vacated $8,957,771.04 of fees for recalculation.
- Bad faith and negligence survive, worth $5 million and $2 million in noneconomic damages plus $136,000 economic, with fees still to be set.
- Nationwide paid a $17,123,927.71 arbitration award in August 2020 on a $200,000 limit, and that payment is unaffected by the appeal.
- IFCA requires an unreasonable denial: tendering the limit on February 7, 2020 resolved any IFCA basis four months before the June 8 notice.
- Division II held in June 2026 that payment does not cure an effective UIM denial; a petition for review filed August 14, 2026 takes that line to the Supreme Court.
What the $103 million was made of
The compensatory phase of trial began on January 23, 2023 in Spokane County Superior Court before Judge Annette Plese, according to the Luvera Law Firm, Shiferaw's counsel. The jury found an IFCA violation, bad faith, a CPA violation and negligence, and awarded $27,136,000 of compensatory damages. In a second phase it added $47 million of punitive damages under Ohio law (Shiferaw v. Nationwide, slip op. at 15 to 16).
The trial court then doubled the IFCA award, adding $20,136,000, and applied a two-times multiplier to the fee lodestar. A second supplemental judgment on May 17, 2023 brought fees and costs to $8,957,771.04 and the total to $103,229,771.04 (slip op. at 17). Nationwide's appeal was argued on October 15, 2025, Law360 reported.
| Component | Trial judgment | After Division III |
|---|---|---|
| Economic damages, all four claims | $136,000 | Affirmed |
| IFCA noneconomic damages | $20,000,000 | Reversed, claim dismissed with prejudice |
| Bad faith noneconomic damages | $5,000,000 | Affirmed |
| Negligence noneconomic damages | $2,000,000 | Affirmed |
| Punitive damages, Ohio law | $47,000,000 | Reversed |
| IFCA enhancement, two times | $20,136,000 | Reversed |
| Attorney fees and costs, two-times multiplier | $8,957,771.04 | Vacated, remanded for redetermination |
| Total | $103,229,771.04 | $7,136,000 plus fees |
Figures from the opinion (slip op. at 15 to 17 and 52). The reversed damages are 84.4% of the judgment; with the fee award vacated, 93.1% goes back to the trial court or disappears.
Where the IFCA line now sits
RCW 48.30.015 gives a first-party claimant "unreasonably denied a claim for coverage or payment of benefits" a cause of action and lets the court award up to three times actual damages. It also requires 20 days' written notice so the insurer can resolve the basis for the action first. The jury here was instructed that Nationwide violated IFCA if it "unreasonably delayed or denied" payment. The court said that instruction "expanded the statute beyond its text" (slip op. at 26).
The claim failed for three reasons. Nationwide tendered the $200,000 limit on February 7, 2020, more than four months before Shiferaw's June 8 IFCA notice, so no benefit remained owing when the cure period began. The benefit was a third-party liability payment to Agere, and the statute does not reach "an insured's complaint about the timing or manner of payment to a third-party claimant" (slip op. at 24). And the plain text requires a denial. The opinion quotes the 2007 legislative history, in which the bill's sponsor withdrew a "delay" amendment and wrote that "the act no longer addresses unreasonable delays in payment of insurance benefits."
"A reasoned (even if ultimately unsuccessful) strategy to protect the insured from excess exposure across jurisdictions is not the equivalent of a refusal to pay a benefit that is due under the policy," the court wrote (Shiferaw v. Nationwide, November 10, 2026, slip op. at 28).
Under Perez-Crisantos v. State Farm (Wash. 2017), a regulatory violation alone does not create an IFCA claim. After Shiferaw, neither does slow payment of a third-party limit. The extracontractual layer on a Washington third-party timing dispute is the excess award itself, common-law bad faith damages, the CPA remedy and fees, with no statutory multiplier. On this file that layer is the $17,123,927.71 award, about $16.9 million above the contract, plus the $7,136,000 the surviving findings carry.
The policy carried $50,000 per person and $100,000 per occurrence, which the out-of-state clause lifted to Alberta's $200,000 minimum (slip op. at 2 to 3). Washington's own floor under RCW 46.29.090 is $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident.
First-party files run the other way. In Labeaume v. First National, decided June 16, 2026, Division II let an IFCA claim proceed where the insurer valued a UIM claim at $77,000 without an independent investigation and later paid the $94,822.80 an arbitrator awarded. An unreasonably low valuation can be an effective denial that payment does not cure, according to Clyde & Co (July 9, 2026). The Shiferaw panel cited Labeaume with approval on UIM facts and noted the petition for review filed on August 14, 2026 (No. 105670-2).
The global-resolution strategy and the malice finding
Agere's counsel began demanding the full limit on October 6, 2017. Nationwide's adjusters wanted a global resolution of every claim, and a third claimant, the truck driver Paul Coyle, had two years under Alberta law to sue and never made a demand. Under Canadian law, the opinion notes, paying $200,000 to Coyle would have obliged Nationwide to offer the same $200,000 to Agere (slip op. at 5).
Agere's final demand on August 12, 2019 said Nationwide was "forcing a husband to sue his wife for his own injuries and the deaths of their children when there is neither a liability nor damages dispute" (slip op. at 4). He sued three days later. Unknown to Nationwide, Coyle had already sued Shiferaw in Alberta on May 16, 2019. The trial court ordered the limit paid within seven days over Nationwide's objection, and the tender landed on February 7, 2020. An arbitrator awarded $17,123,927.71 on June 3, 2020 (slip op. at 8 to 9).
Viewed in Shiferaw's favour, the court said, the record shows "multi-year delays, failure to make an early offer of settlement, inadequate communication, adjustor inexperience, a withheld claims file from Shiferaw's assigned defense counsel, failure to timely appoint panel counsel to defend Shiferaw," and the refusal to toll or settle (slip op. at 31). That supports bad faith and negligence. It falls short of hatred, ill will or conscious disregard, because "Nationwide acted on advice of counsel and pursued a strategy of global resolution" (slip op. at 32). The global-resolution strategy defeated Ohio-law malice, and the jury punished it as bad faith.
Nationwide is an Ohio company and its decisions were made in Ohio, but the policy was issued in Washington and the relationship was "formed, centered, and regulated" there under IFCA and the claims-handling regulations (slip op. at 34 to 35). Under the most-significant-relationship test, Washington law applies, and Washington allows no common-law punitive damages.
Two pieces go back to Judge Plese. Fees must be rebuilt from a fresh lodestar for the surviving claims, and the court "is not bound by its prior decision to apply a two-times multiplier" (slip op. at 46). On Shiferaw's cross-appeal, the denial of a CPA injunction against Nationwide's claims practices was reversed for applying the wrong standard. On remand the court may weigh "regulatory oversight by the Washington State Insurance Commissioner" among the other remedies (slip op. at 50).
Luvera says Nationwide fielded 29 attorneys from four firms against three lawyers and a paralegal. The same judge presides on remand, and the Supreme Court's answer to the Labeaume petition is the next event on the IFCA question.
Further Reading on actuary.info
- Social Inflation Poses a $529 Billion Challenge to Casualty Insurers
- Arkansas Court Orders Walmart's Insurers to Defend 2,400 Opioid Suits
- Triple-I and CAS Price Excess Auto Tort Litigation Two Different Ways
- Texas Insurers Cite Make and Model in 39% of Auto Declinations
- Pennsylvania Superior Court Affirms $725M Exxon Benzene Award in Full
Sources
- Shiferaw v. Nationwide Affinity Insurance Co. of America, No. 39643-6-III, published opinion (Washington Court of Appeals, Division III, November 10, 2026)
- RCW 48.30.015, Unreasonable denial of a claim for coverage or payment of benefits (Washington State Legislature)
- RCW 46.29.090, Motor vehicle liability policy minimum limits (Washington State Legislature)
- Nationwide's $47M punitive award wiped, bad faith finding stands (Insurance Business, November 11, 2026)
- Judge and jury award more than $103 million against Nationwide (Luvera Law Firm)
- Wash. Panel Mulls Trimming $103M Ruling Against Nationwide (Law360, October 15, 2025)
- New Washington Appellate Decision Expands IFCA Risk in UIM Claims (Clyde & Co, July 9, 2026)
- Perez-Crisantos v. State Farm Fire & Casualty Co., 187 Wn.2d 669 (Washington Supreme Court, 2017)
- Beasley v. GEICO General Insurance Co., 23 Wn. App. 2d 641 (Washington Court of Appeals, Division II, 2022)