One hedge position passes the proposed SSAP No. 109 effectiveness corridor at 90.5% when assets plus hedge are measured against the liability. Measured against the asset-liability gap, the denominator the exposure draft uses, the same hedge reads 54%. The example comes from an October 29 letter by the American Academy of Actuaries' Life Investment Analysis Subcommittee to Rachel Hemphill, chair of the NAIC Life Actuarial (A) Task Force (Academy, October 29, 2026).
The letter answers an October 1 presentation to the task force by Kevin Clark, who chairs the Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group, on the draft standard for ALM derivatives. It asks for three changes: effectiveness measured in dollars, the hedge measured against the liability, and no 10-year cap on amortizing deferred gains and losses.
Task force members took up the comments in Dallas on November 13 (LATF agenda, November 13, 2026), the day the Academy's weekly digest listed the letter. The accounting working group meets November 15 with a staff recommendation to expose the draft again.
Key Takeaways
- The Academy's example hedge passes at 90.5% when assets plus hedge are measured against the liability: 2,850 of effective dollar duration against 3,150.
- The same hedge covers 54% of the asset-liability gap under the draft's test: 350 against a difference of 650, outside the 80% to 125% corridor.
- The Academy wants only DV01 or effective dollar duration allowed, because duration alone ranks a $1 billion and a $500 million portfolio as matched.
- The letter asks for amortization over the hedge's remaining life in place of the draft's 10-year cap; its bond example runs 25 years through IMR.
- NAIC staff will ask the accounting working group on November 15 to re-expose the draft with an effective duration method the ACLI drafted.
The worked example
Effective dollar duration in the subcommittee's table is market value times effective duration, the value change for a 100 basis point move in rates.
| Item | Fair, market or notional value | Effective duration | Effective dollar duration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asset | 500 | 5 | 2,500 |
| Hedge | 50 | 7 | 350 |
| Asset plus hedge | 2,850 | ||
| Liability | 525 | 6 | 3,150 |
| Academy's ratio: (asset + hedge) / liability | 90.5% | ||
| Draft's ratio: hedge / (liability minus asset) | 54% |
Source: Academy Life Investment Analysis Subcommittee letter to LATF, October 29, 2026, section 2. Both ratios are the letter's.
Paragraph 13 of the exposure draft defines highly effective as a reduction of the asset-liability duration difference by the hedging derivatives "with between an 80%-125% effective rate" (NAIC, SSAP No. 109 exposure draft, August 2026). On that arithmetic the Academy's hedge would need between 520 and 812.5 of effective dollar duration to pass, 1.5 to 2.3 times the 350 it carries (computed from the letter's table).
Unhedged, the book already scores 79.4%, a shade under the corridor floor, and the hedge lifts it to 90.5%. The subcommittee "is comfortable that the proposed effectiveness test could be utilized in some cases" and calls its own ratio "a more complete picture of a company's risk management."
Dollar duration and the near-zero denominator
Under the draft a company designates modified duration, Macaulay duration or DV01 for each program, and the subcommittee wants the first two removed. "Both modified and Macaulay duration are relative measures of interest rate sensitivity," the letter says. Its example is $1 billion of assets and $500 million of liabilities, each at a duration of 5. They "would appear matched, yet the assets would gain or lose twice as much value as the liabilities for the same change in rates." A swap "typically has a market value near zero, so its duration can be very large or undefined."
Slides the Academy presented the same day work a $100 million asset portfolio at duration 6, a DV01 of $60,000. The liabilities, $100 million at duration 7, carry $70,000 (Academy presentation to LATF, October 29, 2026). A $15 million notional swap at duration 7 adds $10,500 and passes the gap test at 105%. After a 200 basis point fall in rates the gap widens to $16,311 and the unrebalanced hedge reads 69.0%.
Its second complaint is the gap denominator. De minimis differences "could cause hedge effectiveness failures even when total asset and liability durations are tightly matched," the letter says. Should a gap test survive, the subcommittee asks for "a minimum absolute tolerance."
Paragraph 7 already offers a route past a 54% reading: it lets a company hedge "a specific percentage" of the designated item's interest rate sensitivity. A company that designated 54% of the gap in the Academy's example would pass at about 100%; one that designated the whole gap, as the subcommittee's example does, fails.
The ACLI told the accounting working group that regulators had indicated effective duration "could serve as an appropriate effectiveness testing methodology." NAIC staff have inserted the ACLI's draft paragraph 13d and recommend re-exposing the standard at the November 15 hearing (SAPWG hearing agenda, November 15, 2026). Effective duration allows for rate-dependent cash flows, as the Academy wants, and stays a relative measure, which the Academy's letter would keep out of the test.
A 10-year cap on a 30-year hedge
Paragraph 18 of the draft amortizes deferred gains and losses straight-line over the weighted average life of the hedged liability portfolio, "but shall not exceed a period of 10 years." A strict limit "can create an artificial timing mismatch for life insurance, annuity, and other related liabilities, which frequently have cash flows well beyond 10 years," the subcommittee writes. It asks for the period "to align with the remaining life of the hedge."
Its parallel is the interest maintenance reserve. "A 30-year bond purchased five years ago and subsequently sold at a gain would have that gain amortized through IMR over a 25-year period," the letter says. On that schedule a deferred gain of 100 releases 4 a year. Under the cap it releases 10 a year for a decade and nothing after (computed from the letter's example and paragraph 18).
Regulators moved the other way on timing in August: the working group's August 17 referral to the task force lists the removal of the elective accelerated amortization provisions (NAIC, SAPWG referral to LATF, August 17, 2026). Mayer Brown's summer meeting note tied the removal to "regulator concerns about potential manipulation of surplus." The Academy's slides name selective unwinding of hedges to accelerate gains as that concern and offer the tenor-based schedule as the answer.
A longer schedule keeps more of a deferred loss on the balance sheet at any date. NAIC staff ask regulators on November 15 "whether the current 'admitted asset' classification in SSAP No. 109 should be retained without limit." Such losses carried in IMR were nonadmitted before 2023 and then held inside INT 23-01's cap of 10% of capital and surplus, the agenda notes. The site covered the negative IMR framework and the first SSAP 109 exposure in May.
Funds withheld and Modco
A new sentence in paragraph 18 requires deferred balances to be "eliminated and recognized as immediate capital gains and losses upon derecognition of the hedged liability portfolio due to a reinsurance agreement." For traditional coinsurance the subcommittee accepts that. The guidance "does not address varying reinsurance structures where statutory derecognition may not occur strictly, such as Coinsurance with Funds Withheld or Modified Coinsurance (Modco)," it says.
A reinsurer "could maintain the hedge position(s) and strategy as the cedant previously," the letter says. It asks the working group to "explicitly clarify how the immediate recognition provision and ongoing hedge effectiveness testing apply."
Those are the structures behind the offshore annuity blocks the task force has spent the year on, tracked here through the AG 55 guidance that recomputes RBC without the treaty and the E Committee's finding that 70% of cedents to non-reciprocal jurisdictions hold riskier assets. As drafted, a cedant moving a hedged annuity block to an affiliate on a funds withheld basis has to settle whether the liabilities count as derecognized. If they do, the whole deferred balance lands in that quarter.
Pilot companies are to submit their hedge documentation by December 31. They present in regulator-only sessions in late January and February (NAIC, LATF SSAP 109 pilot materials, October 2, 2026). A blanks proposal for Schedule DB reporting lines goes to the Blanks (E) Working Group on December 3. All of it carries a January 1, 2028 effective date.
Further Reading
- NAIC Reshapes Life Insurer Capital With New IMR Framework and SSAP 109
- Academy Shows Why a Thin Baa3 CLO Tranche Carries 12.52% C-1
- NAIC Finds 70% of Non-Reciprocal Cedents Hold Riskier Assets
- NAIC Drafts AG 55 Guidance That Recomputes RBC Without the Treaty
- NAIC Life Task Force Asks for Higher Collateral on Ceded PBR Business
Sources
- American Academy of Actuaries, Life Investment Analysis Subcommittee, “Re: SSAP No. 109 – October 1, 2026 SAPWG Presentation to LATF,” letter to Rachel Hemphill, Chair, Life Actuarial (A) Task Force, actuary.org, October 29, 2026
- American Academy of Actuaries, “Statement of Statutory Accounting Principles (SSAP) 109: Asset Liability Management Derivatives,” presentation to the NAIC Life Actuarial Task Force, actuary.org, October 29, 2026
- NAIC, Life Actuarial (A) Task Force, “SSAP 109 exposure packet” (SAPWG referral to LATF of August 17, 2026; SSAP 109 overview for LATF, October 1, 2026; SSAP No. 109 and Issue Paper No. 1XX, 2026 Summer National Meeting exposure drafts), content.naic.org, October 2, 2026
- NAIC, Life Actuarial (A) Task Force, 2026 Fall National Meeting agenda, Dallas, content.naic.org, draft dated November 3, 2026
- NAIC, Statutory Accounting Principles (E) Working Group, 2026 Fall National Meeting hearing agenda, Ref #2024-15 ALM Derivatives, content.naic.org, dated October 28, 2026 for the November 15 meeting
- American Academy of Actuaries, “This Week: November 9-13, 2026,” actuary.org, November 13, 2026
- Mayer Brown, “US NAIC Summer 2026 National Meeting Highlights: Statutory Accounting Principles Working Group,” mayerbrown.com, August 2026