Under Interpretive Bulletin 95-1, the fiduciary buying a group annuity for a pension plan must take "steps calculated to obtain the safest annuity available" (29 CFR 2509.95-1). Milliman put the competitive price of a retiree buyout at 99.7% of the accounting liability at September 30, 2026 (Milliman, October 2026).
The sponsor funds the same block at the Section 430 segment rates and books it under ASC 715. This reference prices one stylised $100 million block on all three, under the site's life and retirement coverage of the monthly indexes.
Key Takeaways
- A retiree buyout closes in six steps, and the IB 95-1 insurer search weighs six factors.
- One $100 million retiree block carries a $111.0 million funding target at the 2026 segment rates and a $104.9 million PBGC premium funding target.
- Competitive bidding takes the premium 2.9 points below the average insurer's 102.6% (Milliman, October 2026).
- A $100 million lift-out trips the ASC 715 settlement threshold for a frozen $500 million plan, whose interest cost at 6.47% is about $32 million.
- Fiduciaries chose the lowest-cost annuity in 78% of the 2022 retiree lift-outs Aon led (DOL, June 2024).
The Closing Sequence, From Feasibility Study to Plan Amendment
Citing Aon, the DOL's 2024 report to Congress puts 2022 annuity purchases at $52 billion, with lift-outs 43% of transactions and nearly 80% of the value (DOL, June 2024). LIMRA counted 85 buyout contracts for $3.02 billion in the first quarter of 2026, down 57% on the year (LIMRA, July 2026).
Each closed through the same sequence:
- Feasibility and funded status. A lift-out that drops the adjusted funding target attainment percentage below 80% brings on the benefit restrictions in Section 436.
- Data cleanse and death audit. Dates of birth, spouse records, benefit forms and addresses are verified before an insurer prices the census.
- Bid specifications. Bidders receive the census, benefit forms, contract structure (general or separate account) and pricing data. Milliman's index draws its composite rates from nine insurers.
- The IB 95-1 search. An independent fiduciary usually runs it and weighs six factors: portfolio quality and diversification, size relative to the contract, capital and surplus, other lines of business and liabilities, contract structure and guarantees including separate accounts, and state guaranty association coverage. Ratings alone do not meet the duty.
- Premium lock. Insurers price the final bid on a lock date, and the sponsor funds it in cash or assets in kind.
- Contract and plan amendment. Annuitants receive certificates and the plan is amended to remove the transferred benefits. PBGC flat-rate premiums for those participants stop: $116 a head for 2027 plan years (PBGC, October 2026).
A partial buy-out gets the full search: "the safest available annuity standard applies equally in the context of a partial buy-out" (DOL, June 2024).
Three Liabilities and One Premium for a $100 Million Retiree Block
Take a block of about 1,065 retirees averaging $8,500 a year, measured at the 6.47% Milliman 100 discount rate for September 30, 2026 (Milliman, October 2026). For retirees the PBO and ABO coincide, so the accounting liability is $100.0 million. IRS Notice 2026-65 set the 2026 plan-year segment rates at 4.75%, 5.25% and 5.99%, and the September 2026 spot rates the PBGC premium uses at 5.06%, 5.99% and 6.72%.
| Measure | $ million | Basis and source |
|---|---|---|
| Accounting liability (PBO = ABO for retirees), 6.47% | 100.0 | Milliman 100 rate, Sept 30, 2026, standing in for the FTSE AA curve |
| Funding target, 2026 segment rates 4.75% / 5.25% / 5.99% | 111.0 | IRS Notice 2026-65, stabilized rates |
| PBGC premium funding target, Sept 2026 spot 5.06% / 5.99% / 6.72% | 104.9 | IRS Notice 2026-65, unadjusted rates |
| Less: mortality basis refinement in the insurer's study | -2.0 | NISA worked example, collar mix 25% to 50% blue-collar |
| Plus: expense, profit and return on capital, net of asset-spread offset (balancing item) | +1.7 competitive / +4.6 average | Residual to the quoted ratio |
| Competitive buyout premium, 99.7% of ABO | 99.7 | Milliman Pension Buyout Index, Oct 2026 |
| Average buyout premium, 102.6% of ABO | 102.6 | Milliman Pension Buyout Index, Oct 2026 |
| Memo: C-2 longevity capital the insurer holds, 1.71% pre-tax | 1.7 | NAIC LR025-A, first $250 million tier |
| Memo: PBGC flat-rate premium removed, 1,065 x $116 | 0.12 a year, 1.4 PV | PBGC 2027 rate |
Computation: each liability row is 1,065 lives times $8,500 times a 20-year level annuity-immediate at the row's rates, the same stand-in as the site's PBO, ABO and funding target reference. Funding target rows use the first segment for years one to five and the second after. At 6.47% the annuity factor is 11.05 with a modified duration of about 8.0 years, so each 100 basis points moves the block about 8%.
An insurer starts from its own mortality. NISA's worked example moved a $1 billion liability 2% lower when the plan's assumed 25% blue-collar mix was replaced by the actual 50% (NISA, December 2014). The site's piece on WTW's geospatial mortality model covers bid-side mortality.
On top of the refined liability sit administration, profit and the return on capital. NAIC's LR025-A longevity factor requires 1.71% of pre-tax capital on the first $250 million of in-scope reserves (NAIC proposal 2026-07-L, May 2026), $1.7 million here before the C-1 and C-3 asset charges and the covariance step. Milliman's index reads those loads net of the insurer's asset spread. In September the nine insurers' composite rate rose 54 basis points against a 52 basis point rise in the accounting rate, taking the competitive ratio from 99.9% to 99.7% (Milliman, October 2026). The 102.6% average sits 2.9 points higher, the price of a short bid list.
For the sponsor, the PBGC flat-rate premium on 1,065 retirees is about $124,000 a year, or $1.4 million on the same 20-year stand-in. The variable-rate layer is worked through in the site's piece on record PBGC premium pressure.
What the Sponsor Books at the Settlement Date
ASC 715-30 requires settlement accounting when the year's settlements exceed its service cost plus interest cost (FASB ASC 715-30-35-79). For a frozen plan with a $500 million PBO, service cost is zero and interest cost at 6.47% is about $32 million, so a $100 million lift-out trips the threshold. The sponsor then recognises 20% of the net gain or loss held in accumulated other comprehensive income (ASC 715-30-35-82), on top of the $0.3 million difference between the $99.7 million premium and the $100.0 million obligation. Milliman's audit note records that auditors now expect the test each quarter once crossing the threshold is probable (Milliman, October 2020).
Milliman's 100 discount rate fell 27 basis points to 6.20% during October 2026 (Milliman, November 2026), which lifts this block's PBO to $102.2 million. A premium locked at September 30 is measured against the September liability, and the quarter-end remeasurement moves only what stays in the plan. The site's piece on the competitive cost falling below ABO traces that spread.
The Safest-Available Standard After the SECURE 2.0 Review
Section 321 of SECURE 2.0 sent IB 95-1 back to the DOL. After more than 40 stakeholder meetings and an ERISA Advisory Council consultation, the June 2024 report left the six factors as they were, said guidance should "remain principles-based", and added that EBSA "has not concluded that changes to the Interpretive Bulletin are unwarranted" (DOL, June 2024).
Its concern is insurer ownership. Private equity-owned insurers held $534 billion of cash and invested assets in 2022, $509 billion of it in life companies, 9.6% of the industry's assets. Asset-backed securities made up 29% of their bond portfolios against 10.6% at other life insurers (DOL, June 2024, from NAIC data).
Lockheed Martin moved $4.9 billion and about 18,000 participants to Athene in 2021 and 2022, and a Maryland federal court denied dismissal in Konya v. Lockheed Martin. On January 9, 2026 the DOL's amicus brief asked the Fourth Circuit to reverse, arguing that participants still receiving full benefits lack standing (PLANADVISER, January 2026). In Schoen v. ATI, Judge J. Nicholas Ranjan dismissed a challenge to a $1.5 billion transfer on July 27, 2026, since an independent fiduciary had recommended Athene and the plaintiffs had shown no more than an "objectively reasonable likelihood" the insurer would fail (Nixon Peabody, August 2026).
Konya is the first time a federal appeals court will read the six factors against a completed transfer, and no ruling had issued by mid-November 2026.