Exam MAS-II: Credibility Flashcards
Greatest-accuracy credibility for CAS Exam MAS-II: the Bühlmann hypothetical mean and process variance, EPV and VHM, the Bühlmann constant $k=\text{EPV}/\text{VHM}$ and credibility $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}$, the Bühlmann-Straub exposure-weighted extension, nonparametric empirical-Bayes estimation of the structural parameters, semiparametric estimation (Poisson), and the link showing the Bühlmann estimate is the least-squares linear approximation to — and sometimes exactly equals — the Bayesian premium, all carried through fully worked numeric examples.
Every deck is built into the Willys app
All of these decks, including the full practice problem banks, come built into Willys AI Flashcards & Quizzes for iPhone, iPad & Mac, with FSRS + SM-2 spaced repetition, streaks, and exam-date cram mode. 14-day free trial, then $14.99. To load a deck in the app: Settings → Library → Browse, then pick your exam and deck.
More Exam MAS-II decks:
Browse all 44 cards as a list
- Bühlmann modelDefine the **hypothetical mean** $\mu(\theta)$ and the **process variance** $v(\theta)$ in the Bühlmann model.Each risk is characterized by a latent risk parameter $\theta$ drawn from a prior. Conditional on $\theta$: **Hypothetical mean** $\mu(\theta)=E[X\mid\theta]$ — the expected claim for a risk of type $\theta$. **Process variance** $v(\theta)=\text{Var}(X\mid\theta)$ — the within-risk variability of that risk's outcomes. The two structural quantities EPV and VHM are built from these by averaging or taking the variance over the prior of $\theta$.
- EPV & VHMDefine the **expected process variance (EPV)** and the **variance of the hypothetical means (VHM)**.$\text{EPV}=E[v(\theta)]=E[\text{Var}(X\mid\theta)]$ — the average within-risk variance; it measures the noise inside a single risk. $\text{VHM}=\text{Var}[\mu(\theta)]=\text{Var}[E(X\mid\theta)]$ — the spread of the risks' means about the overall mean; it measures how much the risks truly differ. By the variance-decomposition (law of total variance), the total variance of a single observation is $\text{Var}(X)=\text{EPV}+\text{VHM}$.
- Bühlmann modelState the **Bühlmann credibility factor** $Z$ and the **Bühlmann constant** $k$.$k=\dfrac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\dfrac{E[v(\theta)]}{\text{Var}[\mu(\theta)]}$, and with $n$ observations the credibility is $Z=\dfrac{n}{n+k}$. Large within-risk noise (big EPV) or little true difference between risks (small VHM) makes $k$ large and $Z$ small. More data ($n\uparrow$) always pushes $Z\to 1$.
- Bühlmann modelState the **Bühlmann credibility premium** and interpret its two terms.$P_{c}=Z\bar X + (1-Z)\mu$, where $\bar X$ is the risk's own sample mean over $n$ periods and $\mu=E[\mu(\theta)]$ is the overall (collective) mean. It is a weighted average: the risk's own experience $\bar X$ gets weight $Z$ and the manual/collective mean $\mu$ gets weight $1-Z$. As $n\to\infty$, $Z\to 1$ and the premium relies entirely on the risk's own data.
- EPV & VHMWhy does $Z$ increase as VHM grows and decrease as EPV grows?$Z=\frac{n}{n+k}$ with $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}$. A **large VHM** means the risks genuinely differ, so a given risk's own data is very informative about which risk it is — $k$ falls, $Z$ rises. A **large EPV** means each risk's data is noisy, so the sample mean is a poor signal — $k$ rises, $Z$ falls. Limits: as $\text{VHM}\to\infty$, $k\to 0$ and $Z\to 1$; as $\text{EPV}\to\infty$, $k\to\infty$ and $Z\to 0$.
- Credibility-Bayes linkHow is the Bühlmann constant $k$ related to the **full-credibility** standard for credibility? (Limited-fluctuation comparison.)In limited-fluctuation credibility, partial credibility uses $Z=\sqrt{n/n_{0}}$ with $n_{0}$ the full-credibility standard. In **greatest-accuracy (Bühlmann)** credibility, the analogous formula is $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}$: the constant $k$ plays the role of the full-credibility threshold but is derived from the variance structure (EPV/VHM) rather than from a confidence/error tolerance. Both give more weight to larger samples, but Bühlmann's $Z$ is the least-squares-optimal linear weight, not a square-root rule.
- Bühlmann modelWorked: a risk has $\text{EPV}=8000$ and $\text{VHM}=500$. With $n=4$ years of data and overall mean $\mu=1200$, the risk's $\bar X=1500$. Find $k$, $Z$, and the credibility premium.$k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{8000}{500}=16$. $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}=\frac{4}{4+16}=\frac{4}{20}=0.20$. $P_{c}=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu=0.20(1500)+0.80(1200)=300+960=\$1{,}260$. The heavy EPV relative to VHM keeps $Z$ low, so the estimate stays close to the collective mean.
- Bühlmann modelWorked: the same structure has $\text{EPV}=8000$, $\text{VHM}=500$ so $k=16$. How many years $n$ of data are needed for $Z\ge 0.50$?Set $Z=\frac{n}{n+16}\ge 0.50$. $\frac{n}{n+16}=0.50 \Rightarrow n = 0.5(n+16) \Rightarrow 0.5n = 8 \Rightarrow n = 16$. So $n=16$ years gives $Z=0.50$ exactly, and any $n>16$ gives $Z>0.50$. In general $Z=0.5$ precisely when $n=k$, a useful check: the credibility equals one-half when the sample size equals the Bühlmann constant.
- EPV & VHMWorked (variance decomposition): claim counts are $\text{Poisson}(\lambda)$ with $\lambda\sim\text{Gamma}(\alpha=3,\theta=0.1)$. Find $\mu$, EPV, VHM, and $k$.Here $\mu(\lambda)=\lambda$ and $v(\lambda)=\lambda$ (Poisson mean $=$ variance). Gamma mean $E[\lambda]=\alpha\theta=3(0.1)=0.30$; Gamma variance $\text{Var}[\lambda]=\alpha\theta^{2}=3(0.01)=0.03$. $\mu=E[\mu(\lambda)]=E[\lambda]=0.30$. $\text{EPV}=E[v(\lambda)]=E[\lambda]=0.30$. $\text{VHM}=\text{Var}[\mu(\lambda)]=\text{Var}[\lambda]=0.03$. $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{0.30}{0.03}=10$.
- Credibility-Bayes linkContinuing the Poisson-Gamma ($\alpha=3,\theta=0.1$, so $k=10$): a policyholder is observed for $n=5$ years with a total of $4$ claims. Find the Bühlmann credibility estimate of next year's claim count.Risk's sample mean $\bar X=\frac{4}{5}=0.80$ claims/year; overall mean $\mu=0.30$. $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}=\frac{5}{5+10}=\frac{5}{15}=0.3\overline{3}$. $P_{c}=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu=0.3333(0.80)+0.6667(0.30)$ $=0.26667+0.20000=0.46667\approx 0.467$ claims. (For Poisson-Gamma the Bühlmann and exact Bayesian estimates coincide — see the credibility-Bayes link.)
- EPV & VHMWorked (two-type variance decomposition): a portfolio is $60\%$ "good" risks with $\mu=100,\ v=4000$ and $40\%$ "bad" risks with $\mu=300,\ v=9000$. Find $\mu$, EPV, VHM, and $k$.Overall mean $\mu=0.6(100)+0.4(300)=60+120=180$. $\text{EPV}=E[v(\theta)]=0.6(4000)+0.4(9000)=2400+3600=6000$. $\text{VHM}=\text{Var}[\mu(\theta)]=E[\mu^{2}]-\mu^{2}=[0.6(100^{2})+0.4(300^{2})]-180^{2}$ $=[6000+36000]-32400=42000-32400=9600$. $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{6000}{9600}=0.625$.
- Bühlmann modelContinuing the two-type portfolio ($\mu=180$, $k=0.625$): one risk shows $\bar X=250$ over $n=3$ years. Find $Z$ and the credibility premium.$Z=\frac{n}{n+k}=\frac{3}{3+0.625}=\frac{3}{3.625}\approx 0.8276$. $P_{c}=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu=0.8276(250)+0.1724(180)$ $\approx 206.90+31.03=\$237.93$. The large VHM (very different risk types) makes the small constant $k$, so even $3$ years earns high credibility.
- Bühlmann-StraubState the **Bühlmann-Straub** model and how exposures $m_{i}$ change the credibility formula.Bühlmann-Straub allows each period (or cell) $i$ to have a different exposure $m_{i}$ with $X_{i}$ the loss per unit exposure: $E[X_{i}\mid\theta]=\mu(\theta)$ and $\text{Var}(X_{i}\mid\theta)=\frac{v(\theta)}{m_{i}}$. Let $m=\sum_{i} m_{i}$ be total exposure. Then $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}$ as before, but $Z=\frac{m}{m+k}$, and the risk's mean is exposure-weighted: $\bar X=\frac{\sum_i m_i X_i}{m}$.
- Bühlmann-StraubIn Bühlmann-Straub, why is the credibility-weighted sample mean computed as $\bar X=\frac{\sum_i m_i X_i}{\sum_i m_i}$ rather than a simple average of the $X_i$?Periods with more exposure $m_i$ carry more information and less noise (their conditional variance $v(\theta)/m_i$ is smaller), so they should weight more heavily. The exposure-weighted mean is the minimum-variance unbiased combination of the $X_i$, and it is what the Bühlmann-Straub credibility estimate uses. The ordinary Bühlmann model is the special case $m_i=1$ for all $i$, which collapses $\bar X$ to the simple average and $Z$ to $\frac{n}{n+k}$.
- Bühlmann-StraubWorked Bühlmann-Straub: $\text{EPV}=10000$, $\text{VHM}=200$, $\mu=50$ per exposure. A risk has exposures and pure premiums: Year 1: $m=20,\ X=60$; Year 2: $m=30,\ X=45$; Year 3: $m=50,\ X=58$. Find the credibility premium.Total exposure $m=20+30+50=100$. Weighted mean $\bar X=\frac{20(60)+30(45)+50(58)}{100}=\frac{1200+1350+2900}{100}=\frac{5450}{100}=54.5$. $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{10000}{200}=50$. $Z=\frac{m}{m+k}=\frac{100}{100+50}=\frac{100}{150}=0.6\overline{6}$. $P_{c}=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu=0.6667(54.5)+0.3333(50)=36.33+16.67=\$53.00$ per exposure.
- Bühlmann-StraubWorked Bühlmann-Straub (expected claims): in the previous example ($Z=0.6\overline{6}$, $P_c=\$53.00$ per exposure), if next year's exposure is projected at $m_{new}=40$, what is the expected total credibility loss?The credibility premium $\$53.00$ is a rate **per exposure unit**. Multiply by next year's exposure: Expected loss $=P_{c}\times m_{new}=53.00\times 40=\$2{,}120$. Keep the per-exposure rate distinct from the dollar total — credibility is applied to the rate, then scaled to the projected exposure.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)What is the **nonparametric empirical-Bayes** problem, and what data layout does it assume?When the prior distribution of $\theta$ is unknown, we estimate the structural parameters $\mu$, EPV, and VHM **directly from the data** rather than from assumed model forms. Classic layout: $r$ risks (policyholders), each observed for $n$ periods, giving a two-way table $X_{ij}$ ($i=1,\dots,r$ risks; $j=1,\dots,n$ years). From it we form per-risk means $\bar X_i$, the grand mean $\bar X$, and within-risk sample variances $s_i^2$ to estimate $\hat\mu$, $\widehat{\text{EPV}}$, and $\widehat{\text{VHM}}$.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Give the nonparametric empirical-Bayes estimator of the **overall mean** $\hat\mu$ ($r$ risks, $n$ years each).$\hat\mu=\bar X=\frac{1}{rn}\sum_{i=1}^{r}\sum_{j=1}^{n}X_{ij}=\frac{1}{r}\sum_{i=1}^{r}\bar X_i$, the grand mean of all observations (equivalently, the average of the per-risk means when every risk has the same number of years $n$). When exposures differ (Bühlmann-Straub), the grand mean is exposure-weighted instead.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Give the nonparametric empirical-Bayes estimator of the **EPV**.$\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\frac{1}{r}\sum_{i=1}^{r}s_i^{2}$, the average of the per-risk sample variances, where $s_i^{2}=\frac{1}{n-1}\sum_{j=1}^{n}(X_{ij}-\bar X_i)^{2}$. Each $s_i^2$ is an unbiased estimate of that risk's process variance $v(\theta_i)$, so averaging over the $r$ risks estimates $E[v(\theta)]=\text{EPV}$. (With unequal years, use a pooled within-risk variance: $\sum_i\sum_j (X_{ij}-\bar X_i)^2 \big/ \sum_i (n_i-1)$.)
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Give the nonparametric empirical-Bayes estimator of the **VHM** and the rule when it comes out negative.$\widehat{\text{VHM}}=\frac{1}{r-1}\sum_{i=1}^{r}(\bar X_i-\bar X)^{2}-\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}$. The first term is the sample variance of the per-risk means; it overstates VHM because each $\bar X_i$ carries process noise of size $\frac{v(\theta)}{n}$, so we subtract $\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}$ to remove it. Because this is a difference, it can be **negative**; a negative estimate is set to $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=0$ (which forces $Z=0$, i.e. give the risk no own-experience weight).
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Why does the empirical-Bayes VHM estimator subtract $\widehat{\text{EPV}}/n$ from the between-risk sample variance?Each per-risk mean $\bar X_i$ estimates the true hypothetical mean $\mu(\theta_i)$ but with sampling error of variance $\frac{v(\theta_i)}{n}$. So the observed spread of the $\bar X_i$ contains **both** the genuine between-risk variability (VHM) **and** this estimation noise, on average $\frac{\text{EPV}}{n}$. $E\!\left[\frac{1}{r-1}\sum_i(\bar X_i-\bar X)^2\right]=\text{VHM}+\frac{\text{EPV}}{n}$, so subtracting $\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}$ makes the estimator unbiased for VHM.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Fully worked nonparametric empirical Bayes. Three risks, each observed $n=4$ years: Risk A: 8, 10, 9, 13; Risk B: 5, 7, 6, 6; Risk C: 12, 14, 11, 15. Compute the per-risk means and the grand mean $\hat\mu$.Risk A: $\bar X_A=\frac{8+10+9+13}{4}=\frac{40}{4}=10$. Risk B: $\bar X_B=\frac{5+7+6+6}{4}=\frac{24}{4}=6$. Risk C: $\bar X_C=\frac{12+14+11+15}{4}=\frac{52}{4}=13$. Grand mean $\hat\mu=\bar X=\frac{10+6+13}{3}=\frac{29}{3}\approx 9.6667$. (With equal years, averaging the three risk means equals averaging all $12$ observations.)
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Same data (A: 8,10,9,13; B: 5,7,6,6; C: 12,14,11,15; $n=4$, $\bar X_A=10,\bar X_B=6,\bar X_C=13$). Compute the within-risk sample variances $s_i^2$ and $\widehat{\text{EPV}}$.Use $s_i^2=\frac{1}{n-1}\sum_j(X_{ij}-\bar X_i)^2$ with $n-1=3$. Risk A: deviations $-2,0,-1,3$; squares $4,0,1,9$; sum $=14$; $s_A^2=\frac{14}{3}\approx 4.6667$. Risk B: deviations $-1,1,0,0$; squares $1,1,0,0$; sum $=2$; $s_B^2=\frac{2}{3}\approx 0.6667$. Risk C: deviations $-1,1,-2,2$; squares $1,1,4,4$; sum $=10$; $s_C^2=\frac{10}{3}\approx 3.3333$. $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\frac{1}{r}\sum_i s_i^2=\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{14+2+10}{3}\right)=\frac{26}{9}\approx 2.8889$.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Same data ($\bar X_A=10,\bar X_B=6,\bar X_C=13$; $\hat\mu=\frac{29}{3}$; $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\frac{26}{9}$; $r=3$, $n=4$). Compute $\widehat{\text{VHM}}$.Between-risk sum of squares $\sum_i(\bar X_i-\bar X)^2$ with $\bar X=\frac{29}{3}\approx 9.6667$: A: $(10-9.6667)^2=(0.3333)^2\approx 0.1111$; B: $(6-9.6667)^2=(-3.6667)^2\approx 13.4444$; C: $(13-9.6667)^2=(3.3333)^2\approx 11.1111$. Sum $\approx 24.6667$. Divide by $r-1=2$: $\frac{24.6667}{2}=12.3333$. $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=12.3333-\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}=12.3333-\frac{2.8889}{4}=12.3333-0.7222\approx 11.6111$.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Same data ($\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\frac{26}{9}\approx 2.8889$, $\widehat{\text{VHM}}\approx 11.6111$, $n=4$). Find $\hat k$ and $\hat Z$.$\hat k=\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{\widehat{\text{VHM}}}=\frac{2.8889}{11.6111}\approx 0.2488$. $\hat Z=\frac{n}{n+\hat k}=\frac{4}{4+0.2488}=\frac{4}{4.2488}\approx 0.9414$. The risks are very different (large VHM) relative to within-risk noise (small EPV), so each risk earns high credibility on only $4$ years.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Same data ($\hat\mu=\frac{29}{3}\approx 9.6667$, $\hat Z\approx 0.9414$). Find the empirical-Bayes credibility premiums for Risks A, B, and C, and verify they sum back to the total.$P_i=\hat Z\,\bar X_i+(1-\hat Z)\hat\mu$ with $1-\hat Z\approx 0.0586$ and $(1-\hat Z)\hat\mu\approx 0.0586(9.6667)\approx 0.5665$. Risk A: $0.9414(10)+0.5665=9.414+0.5665\approx 9.98$. Risk B: $0.9414(6)+0.5665=5.648+0.5665\approx 6.22$. Risk C: $0.9414(13)+0.5665=12.238+0.5665\approx 12.80$. Balance check: $9.98+6.22+12.80=29.00=3\hat\mu=3(9.6667)$ — the credibility premiums preserve the grand total (the estimator is balanced).
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Why must the empirical-Bayes credibility premiums satisfy the **balance** condition $\sum_i n_i P_i=\sum_i n_i\bar X_i$?Because $P_i=Z\bar X_i+(1-Z)\hat\mu$ and $\hat\mu=\bar X$ is the (exposure-weighted) grand mean, averaging the $P_i$ over the same weights returns $\hat\mu$: $\sum_i n_i P_i = Z\sum_i n_i\bar X_i+(1-Z)\hat\mu\sum_i n_i=\sum_i n_i\bar X_i$. Practically, this means crediting individual risks toward the mean does **not** change the total premium collected — credibility redistributes premium among risks but is revenue-neutral in aggregate.
- SemiparametricWhat is **semiparametric** estimation in credibility, and when is it used?Semiparametric estimation assumes a **parametric form for the conditional distribution** of the data (so the process variance is a known function of the mean) but leaves the **prior** of $\theta$ unspecified, estimating its features empirically. The headline case is claim counts modeled as conditionally **Poisson**, where $v(\theta)=\mu(\theta)$, so the EPV equals the overall mean and need not be estimated from within-risk variances — it is read straight off $\hat\mu=\bar X$.
- SemiparametricGive the **semiparametric (Poisson)** estimators of EPV and VHM.If counts are conditionally Poisson then $v(\theta)=\mu(\theta)$, so $\text{EPV}=E[v(\theta)]=E[\mu(\theta)]=\mu$. Hence $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\bar X$ (the overall mean). VHM is still estimated from the spread of risk means with the noise correction: $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=\frac{1}{r-1}\sum_i(\bar X_i-\bar X)^2-\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}$ (set to $0$ if negative). The only difference from nonparametric is that EPV comes from the Poisson identity, not from within-risk sample variances.
- SemiparametricFully worked semiparametric (Poisson). $400$ policyholders each observed $1$ year. Claim-count distribution: 0 claims: 280 policies; 1 claim: 90; 2 claims: 24; 3 claims: 6. Estimate $\widehat{\text{EPV}}$ via the Poisson identity.Total claims $=0(280)+1(90)+2(24)+3(6)=90+48+18=156$. Total policies $=280+90+24+6=400$. $\bar X=\frac{156}{400}=0.39$ claims/policy. Under the conditional-Poisson assumption $\text{EPV}=\mu$, so $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\bar X=0.39$.
- SemiparametricContinuing the Poisson semiparametric example ($n=1$ year per policy, $\bar X=0.39$, $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=0.39$): estimate the **total sample variance** of claim counts, then $\widehat{\text{VHM}}$.Mean of squares: $\frac{0^2(280)+1^2(90)+2^2(24)+3^2(6)}{400}=\frac{0+90+96+54}{400}=\frac{240}{400}=0.60$. Sample variance $\hat\sigma^2=E[X^2]-\bar X^2=0.60-0.39^2=0.60-0.1521=0.4479$ (this estimates total variance $=\text{EPV}+\text{VHM}$ when $n=1$). $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=\hat\sigma^2-\widehat{\text{EPV}}=0.4479-0.39=0.0579$. (Equivalently the between-policy variance of the single-year means minus EPV; with $n=1$ the two coincide.)
- SemiparametricFinishing the Poisson semiparametric example ($\widehat{\text{EPV}}=0.39$, $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=0.0579$, $n=1$): find $\hat k$ and the credibility estimate for a policyholder who had $2$ claims in the year.$\hat k=\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{\widehat{\text{VHM}}}=\frac{0.39}{0.0579}\approx 6.736$. $\hat Z=\frac{n}{n+\hat k}=\frac{1}{1+6.736}=\frac{1}{7.736}\approx 0.1293$. For a policy with $\bar X=2$: $P_c=\hat Z(2)+(1-\hat Z)(0.39)=0.1293(2)+0.8707(0.39)$ $\approx 0.2586+0.3396=0.598\approx 0.60$ claims. With just one year and modest VHM, the estimate barely moves off the $0.39$ mean.
- Credibility-Bayes linkState the **credibility-Bayes link**: in what sense is the Bühlmann estimate "the best" approximation to the Bayesian premium?The exact Bayesian premium is $E[\mu(\theta)\mid X_1,\dots,X_n]$, the posterior mean of the hypothetical mean. The **Bühlmann credibility premium** $Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu$ is the **least-squares linear approximation** to that Bayesian estimate — it minimizes $E\big[(\,\text{Bayesian premium}-(a+b\bar X)\,)^2\big]$ over all linear functions of the data. Thus Bühlmann is the best *linear* estimator; it trades the exact (possibly nonlinear) Bayes rule for a simple, robust line.
- Credibility-Bayes linkWhen does the Bühlmann credibility estimate equal the **exact Bayesian** premium?When the Bayesian premium is already a **linear** function of the data — the exact-credibility (linear-conjugate) families. Key cases on the syllabus: • **Poisson likelihood with Gamma prior** (claim counts); • **Normal likelihood with Normal prior** (severity/means); • **Bernoulli/Binomial with Beta prior**; • **Exponential/Gamma likelihood with appropriate conjugate prior**. For these the posterior mean is exactly $Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu$, so Bühlmann and Bayes coincide and no approximation is lost.
- Credibility-Bayes linkWorked credibility-Bayes (Poisson-Gamma exact). Counts are $\text{Poisson}(\lambda)$, prior $\lambda\sim\text{Gamma}(\alpha=2,\ \beta=4)$ (rate $\beta$, so $E[\lambda]=\alpha/\beta=0.5$). Observe $n=3$ years totaling $S=3$ claims. Find the Bayesian (posterior-mean) estimate.Gamma-Poisson conjugacy: posterior is $\text{Gamma}(\alpha+S,\ \beta+n)=\text{Gamma}(2+3,\ 4+3)=\text{Gamma}(5,\ 7)$. Posterior mean $=\frac{\alpha+S}{\beta+n}=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143$ claims. This is the exact Bayesian predictive mean for next year's count.
- Credibility-Bayes linkVerify the previous Poisson-Gamma result with the **Bühlmann** formula, showing the two agree. (Prior $\text{Gamma}(\alpha=2,\beta=4)$ rate-form; $n=3$, $\bar X=1$.)With rate-$\beta$ Gamma: $\mu=E[\lambda]=\frac{\alpha}{\beta}=\frac{2}{4}=0.5$, $\text{EPV}=E[\lambda]=0.5$, $\text{VHM}=\text{Var}[\lambda]=\frac{\alpha}{\beta^2}=\frac{2}{16}=0.125$. $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{0.5}{0.125}=4=\beta$ (indeed $k=\beta$ for Gamma-Poisson). $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}=\frac{3}{3+4}=\frac{3}{7}$; $\bar X=\frac{3}{3}=1$. $P_c=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu=\frac{3}{7}(1)+\frac{4}{7}(0.5)=\frac{3}{7}+\frac{2}{7}=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143$. Identical to the posterior mean — exact credibility holds.
- Credibility-Bayes linkWorked credibility-Bayes (Normal-Normal exact). Severity $X\mid\theta\sim N(\theta,\ \sigma^2=100)$ with prior $\theta\sim N(\mu_0=50,\ \tau^2=25)$. Observe $n=4$ values averaging $\bar X=60$. Find the posterior-mean (Bayesian) estimate.Normal-Normal posterior mean is a precision-weighted average: $Z=\frac{n\tau^2}{n\tau^2+\sigma^2}=\frac{4(25)}{4(25)+100}=\frac{100}{200}=0.5$. Posterior mean $=Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu_0=0.5(60)+0.5(50)=30+25=55$. Equivalently $k=\frac{\sigma^2}{\tau^2}=\frac{100}{25}=4=\text{EPV}/\text{VHM}$, giving $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}=\frac{4}{8}=0.5$ — the Bühlmann $Z$ matches, so Bühlmann equals Bayes here too.
- Credibility-Bayes linkFor the Normal-Normal model, show that the Bühlmann constant $k$ equals $\sigma^2/\tau^2$.$\mu(\theta)=\theta$ and $v(\theta)=\text{Var}(X\mid\theta)=\sigma^2$ (constant), so $\text{EPV}=E[\sigma^2]=\sigma^2$. $\text{VHM}=\text{Var}[\mu(\theta)]=\text{Var}[\theta]=\tau^2$. Therefore $k=\frac{\text{EPV}}{\text{VHM}}=\frac{\sigma^2}{\tau^2}$ and $Z=\frac{n}{n+\sigma^2/\tau^2}=\frac{n\tau^2}{n\tau^2+\sigma^2}$, exactly the Bayesian posterior-mean weight — Normal-Normal is an exact-credibility model.
- Credibility-Bayes linkContrast the **Bühlmann** estimate, the **Bayesian** estimate, and the **limited-fluctuation** estimate of a future premium.**Bayesian:** $E[\mu(\theta)\mid \text{data}]$ — the full posterior mean; can be nonlinear in the data; requires the entire model (likelihood + prior). **Bühlmann (greatest-accuracy):** $Z\bar X+(1-Z)\mu$ with $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}$ — the least-squares linear approximation to Bayes; needs only $\mu$, EPV, VHM; equals Bayes for conjugate-linear models. **Limited-fluctuation (classical):** $Z\bar X+(1-Z)M$ with $Z=\min\!\big(\sqrt{n/n_0},1\big)$ — a square-root partial-credibility rule from a full-credibility standard $n_0$; not derived from the variance structure and generally not the optimal linear estimator.
- Credibility-Bayes linkWorked comparison: Poisson-Gamma with prior $\text{Gamma}(\alpha=3,\beta=2)$ (rate form, $E[\lambda]=1.5$); a risk shows total claims $S=12$ over $n=5$ years ($\bar X=2.4$). Compute both the Bühlmann and the exact Bayesian estimate and confirm equality.Structure: $\mu=\frac{\alpha}{\beta}=\frac{3}{2}=1.5$, $\text{EPV}=1.5$, $\text{VHM}=\frac{\alpha}{\beta^2}=\frac{3}{4}=0.75$, so $k=\frac{1.5}{0.75}=2$. $Z=\frac{5}{5+2}=\frac{5}{7}\approx 0.7143$. Bühlmann: $P_c=\frac{5}{7}(2.4)+\frac{2}{7}(1.5)=\frac{12+3}{7}=\frac{15}{7}\approx 2.143$. Bayes: with total claims $S=12$ (an integer Poisson count), posterior $\text{Gamma}(3+12,\ 2+5)=\text{Gamma}(15,7)$, mean $\frac{15}{7}\approx 2.143$. They agree exactly.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)In empirical Bayes, what does it mean — and what do you do — when $\widehat{\text{VHM}}\le 0$?A non-positive $\widehat{\text{VHM}}$ means the observed spread among the risk means is no larger than what the within-risk process noise $\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}$ alone would produce — there is no statistical evidence the risks truly differ. The convention is to set $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=0$, which makes $\hat k=\infty$ and therefore $\hat Z=0$. Every risk is then charged the grand mean $\hat\mu$: with no detectable heterogeneity, individual experience earns zero credibility.
- Empirical Bayes (nonparametric)Worked empirical Bayes producing $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=0$. Two risks, $n=3$ years each — Risk 1: 4, 6, 5; Risk 2: 5, 4, 6. Show the credibility collapses to the mean.Means: $\bar X_1=\frac{15}{3}=5$, $\bar X_2=\frac{15}{3}=5$; grand mean $\hat\mu=5$. Within-risk variances: each set $\{4,5,6\}$ has $s^2=\frac{1+0+1}{2}=1$, so $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\frac{1+1}{2}=1$. Between-risk: $\frac{1}{r-1}\sum(\bar X_i-\bar X)^2=\frac{(5-5)^2+(5-5)^2}{1}=0$. $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=0-\frac{\widehat{\text{EPV}}}{n}=0-\frac{1}{3}<0\Rightarrow$ set to $0$. Then $\hat Z=0$ and both risks are charged $\hat\mu=5$ — identical means give no evidence of heterogeneity.
- Bühlmann-StraubWorked Bühlmann-Straub empirical Bayes with unequal exposures. Two risks: Risk 1: year exposures/losses $(m,X)=(10,4.0),(20,5.0)$; Risk 2: $(30,7.0),(40,6.5)$. Find the exposure-weighted risk means and the grand mean.Risk 1 total exposure $m_1=10+20=30$; weighted mean $\bar X_1=\frac{10(4.0)+20(5.0)}{30}=\frac{40+100}{30}=\frac{140}{30}\approx 4.667$. Risk 2 total exposure $m_2=30+40=70$; weighted mean $\bar X_2=\frac{30(7.0)+40(6.5)}{70}=\frac{210+260}{70}=\frac{470}{70}\approx 6.714$. Grand (exposure-weighted) mean $\hat\mu=\frac{10(4.0)+20(5.0)+30(7.0)+40(6.5)}{100}=\frac{40+100+210+260}{100}=\frac{610}{100}=6.10$. The grand mean uses total exposure $m=30+70=100$ as the denominator, not a simple average of the two risk means.
- Credibility-Bayes linkSummarize the **decision flow** for choosing a credibility method on an exam problem.1. **Prior fully specified** (parametric likelihood + prior given)? Compute $\mu$, EPV, VHM analytically; use Bühlmann $Z=\frac{n}{n+k}$, or get the exact Bayesian posterior mean (they match for conjugate-linear models). 2. **Exposures vary across cells**? Use **Bühlmann-Straub**: $Z=\frac{m}{m+k}$, exposure-weighted $\bar X$. 3. **Prior unknown, raw two-way data given**? Use **nonparametric empirical Bayes**: $\hat\mu=\bar X$, $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\overline{s_i^2}$, $\widehat{\text{VHM}}=$ between-variance $-\widehat{\text{EPV}}/n$. 4. **Counts known to be Poisson but prior unknown**? Use **semiparametric**: $\widehat{\text{EPV}}=\bar X$, then VHM as in step 3.